Posts

“On Tyranny” - Chapter 9: "Be kind to our language"

Image
This chapter, it seems to me, is less about “being kind” to language than recognizing language’s power, not just to communicate outwardly with others, but as the means by which we frame and order out thoughts and take in the messages from without. Snyder here is asking us to be aware of the epistemic nature of thought and words and how we as individuals can shore up and reinforce thinking independently and critically while offering tools on how to do so. Snyder introduces us to Victor Klemperer, a phonologist and scholar of Jewish origin who used his training to combat Nazi propaganda. He noticed how.the a term like “the people” was exclusionary; it meant some but not all people. This may seem tangential, but I don’t think it is: the term of “people” in German is   Volk , and had been used, particularly in the 18th and 19th centuries as equivalent to “national spirit”. This was part of a larger philosophical movement that sought to identify the uniqueness of the German people withi...

“On Tyranny” - Chapter 8: "Stand out"

Image
We’ve heard, possibly ad nauseam, that history repeats itself or that it rhymes or that it echos. In any case, we are witnessing a scenario that played out across the twentieth and seems to be playing out again in the twenty-first; the fall of democracy across the planet. We are also experiencing the fall of an empire.  Make no mistake, US foreign policy has been built on the idea of “Manifest Destiny” and this was assumed to be a universal axiom. It began as justification for the Western movement in the nineteenth century with all the acquisition of native lands possible and land grabs from Mexico and Spain, not to mention the crazy bargain basement buy-out of the Louisiana Purchase. Post Civil War, we see the U.S. expansionism begin across the globe, very often via armed takeover, but later in the twentieth century, by way of “soft” and not-so-soft, power.  With increased globalization, it’s obvious there would be those who would challenge US hegemony, but realistically, it’...

“On Tyranny” - Chapter 7: "Be reflective if you must be armed"

Image
"If you carry a weapon in public service, may God bless you and keep you. But know that evils of the past involved policemen and soldiers finding themselves, one day, doing irregular things. Be ready to say no." Snyder opens with a historical look back at the special riot and secret police forces used by authoritarian regimes. Reference is made to their employment in the Great Terror in the Soviet Union and the Holocaust perpetrated by the Nazi regime. What he emphasizes is that the Nazi SS and the Soviet NKVD didn't act with out support.  "Without the assistance of regular police forces, and sometimes regular soldiers, they could not have killed on such a large scale." Moreover, the NKVD might have been the most well-organized of any mass killing group. It was centralized and the officers "recorded 682,691 executions of supposed enemies of the state, most of them peasants or members of national minorities." These executions might have been carried out...

“On Tyranny” - Chapter 6: "Be wary of paramilitaries"

Image
This might seem obvious, but Snyder’s points are subtler. Would we know when a paramilitary or a troop of assembled paramilitaries has decided to secure a neighborhood, town, region? We think so, of course. Even absent Trumpian direct support, there’s a good likelihood that in some parts of the United States, people would actually be supportive of an occupying force to enforce the rampant scourges of liberals, LGBTQ+ people, immigrants, and BIPOC people.  With   government support? Then we’d be very much in SS territory.  Is this and the following chapter alarmist? It’s difficult to say. We live in a country where guns outnumber people, where the Second Amendment is enshrined as a religious text and where we have grown inured to mass shootings. In areas where gun owning and open carry or even concealed carry without a license is a sign of vigilance and damn near a moral duty, is it really such a stretch to imagine seeing a militarized “neighborhood watch”? Snyder opens th...

“On Tyranny” - Chapter 5: “Remember professional ethics”

Image
  This injunction is targeted for professionals in various areas of law, medicine, and politics. It might seem abstruse to many - it did for me, at least on the first read or two - but it speaks to a larger and deeper ethical framework that is supposed to underpin these professions. Snyder points out how valuable lawyers were to the Third Reich in implementing perception, mass murder, and genocide. The ability to maintain a facade of professional legitimacy in the face of immoral acts of the highest order and broadest reach is integral to ensuring an enthusiastic, if not merely complacent, populace.  Rather like the Milgram Experiment, all it takes is the voice of an authority to wipe away conscience and shore up one’s belief that what they are doing is right.  Snyder recounts how businessmen were all in in the construction of the camps, how lawyers crafted the annexation of Austria and the Netherlands, and how, most damningly, physicians put away the Hippocratic oath to ...